Tesla’s 2025 CEO Performance Award: Aligning Vision, Execution & Shareholder Value

In business — as in life — incentives drive behavior. Get them wrong, and you get mediocrity. Get them right, and you get Tesla.

Few compensation structures in corporate history have generated as much debate as Elon Musk’s. But viewed through the lens of long-term ownership — the only lens that truly matters — it becomes clear: this is not about money. It’s about alignment, execution, and mission control.

Over the past decade, Musk’s prior compensation plans have delivered extraordinary results for shareholders. The 2012 CEO Performance Award helped lift Tesla from under $4 billion in market cap to well over $55 billion within just a few years. The 2018 Award — approved by nearly three-quarters of independent shareholders — set the stage for Tesla’s growth to more than $1 trillion in market value. Both programs were 100% performance-based, with no salary, no cash bonus, and no guaranteed equity. Musk only got paid when shareholders did.

With shareholders set to vote by November 6, Tesla’s board is putting forward the 2025 CEO Performance Award (see proxy here)— a bold new 10-year plan that realigns Musk with Tesla’s next chapter: AI, autonomy, energy, and robotics — and restores and restores the all-or-nothing performance philosophy that made Tesla what it is today.

A Look Back: Elon Musk’s 2012 CEO Performance Award

Context

Back in 2012, Tesla was a niche automaker with a market cap under $4 billion. The Model S hadn’t even rolled off the production line yet, and Musk’s now-famous Master Plan — to build affordable electric cars and scale to mass production — was still just a vision.

Structure

The plan granted 10 tranches of stock options, each requiring:

1. a $4 billion increase in Tesla’s market capitalization, and

2. achievement of a major operational milestone — such as a new vehicle launch, production target, or profitability goal.

   
   

No salary. No cash bonus. 100% performance-based.

For Musk to earn the full award, Tesla’s market cap had to rise to roughly $43 billion — more than tenfold growth.

Outcome

The results were extraordinary. Within five years, Tesla’s market cap climbed from under $4 billion to over $55 billion. Musk delivered the Model S, Model X, and Model 3, expanding the company into energy generation and storage along the way.

Shareholders took notice — Tesla’s “Say on Pay” votes passed with over 94% (2014) and 99% (2017) support. The 2012 award proved a simple truth: when you align incentives with outcomes, innovation follows.

The 2018 CEO Performance Award: Scaling the Vision

Context

By 2017, Tesla had completed its 2012 plan and was entering a new era. The company’s market cap had reached roughly $60 billion, already larger than any North American automaker. The board’s challenge was clear: how to keep Musk’s focus squarely on Tesla amid his growing universe of ventures — SpaceX, Neuralink, and The Boring Company — while driving the next phase of growth.

Structure

The answer came in another bold, all-or-nothing plan.

• No salary. No cash bonus. No time-based equity.

• 12 tranches of stock options, each representing 1% of Tesla’s shares outstanding at the time, would vest only if both of the following conditions were met:

  1. Tesla’s market capitalization increased by $50 billion per tranche, from $100 billion to $650 billion, and

  2. The company achieved a series of operational and financial milestones — including ambitious revenue and EBITDA targets.

     
     

To ensure enduring alignment, Musk was also required to hold all vested shares for five years. The plan was approved at a special shareholder meeting with 73% support, excluding votes from Elon and Kimbal Musk.

Board’s Rationale

The logic behind the plan was straightforward:

1. No results, no pay — pure performance alignment.

2. Maintain Musk’s long-term focus on Tesla despite his other ventures.

3. Execute “Master Plan, Part Deux” — expanding Tesla’s reach into energy generation, storage, autonomous driving, and mass-market vehicles.

   
   

Outcome

Within just four years, Tesla’s valuation exploded past $650 billion, triggering all 12 tranches. The company became the most valuable automaker in history — and one of the fastest-growing enterprises the market has ever seen.

Though the plan was later challenged in Delaware courts on procedural grounds, its impact is undeniable: it created over $600 billion in shareholder value, validating once again that true pay-for-performance works when incentives are tied to long-term results.

Key Takeaway

From 2012 to 2018 to 2025, the evolution of Elon Musk’s compensation has been remarkably consistent — a masterclass in alignment. Each plan has shared the same DNA: zero cash pay, all-or-nothing equity, and alignment before reward.

Every iteration has simply scaled with Tesla’s ambition — from a $4 billion startup to a $1 trillion powerhouse — and every time, it has delivered extraordinary results for long-term shareholders.

The 2025 plan carries this lineage forward, reaffirming a timeless principle: when leadership’s incentives mirror those of owners, value creation compounds.

Tesla’s Third Act: The 2025 CEO Performance Award

Building on the success of the 2012 and 2018 plans, Tesla’s next chapter extends the same pay-for-performance philosophy — one rooted in execution, innovation, and long-term alignment.

Each of Musk’s previous compensation plans powered a distinct phase of Tesla’s evolution:

• 2012: The startup phase — proving an electric car company could survive.

• 2018: The scale phase — transforming Tesla into one of the most valuable enterprises on Earth.

  
  

Now, in 2025, Tesla enters its third act — a transformation from an EV and energy company into a full-fledged AI and robotics platform. This next stage demands a compensation structure that reflects both the scale of the opportunity and the weight of the mission.

Structure of the 2025 CEO Performance Award

• Term: 10 years (2025–2035)

• Form: 100% performance-based restricted stock

• Tranches: 12 equal tranches

• Strike Price: Roughly $350 per share

• Vesting: Each tranche vests only when Tesla achieves both a market cap milestone and a performance milestone

• No Salary, No Bonus: Musk earns nothing unless shareholders gain massively

• Holding Period: Multi-year lockup after vesting to ensure long-term alignment

  
  

Market Capitalization Milestones

The plan envisions Tesla’s journey from roughly $1 trillion today to $8.5 trillion by 2035 — an eightfold increase in shareholder value.

Each tranche corresponds to a roughly $500–$700 billion rise in market capitalization, representing about $7 trillion in total value creation if all are achieved.

Financial Milestones — EBITDA Targets

To complement those valuation goals, Tesla must also achieve eight consecutive EBITDA milestones, ranging from $50 billion to $400 billion in trailing twelve-month operating earnings. For context, Tesla’s current EBITDA is around $11–12 billion — meaning the very first milestone alone requires nearly a five-fold increase in operating performance, and the top milestone represents roughly a 35–40x leap. These goals are designed not for incremental growth, but for transformation — demanding near-flawless execution across vehicles, energy storage, software, and AI infrastructure.

Strategic Product Execution Milestones

In addition to financial performance, four product milestones define Tesla’s innovation roadmap for the decade ahead:

1. 20 Million Vehicles Delivered — scaling affordability and strengthening Tesla’s real-world driving data.

2. 10 Million Active FSD Subscriptions — creating a recurring, high-margin AI-driven software business.

3. Commercial Launch of the Tesla Robotaxi Network — monetizing idle vehicles through autonomous ride-hailing.

4. Deployment of Optimus Humanoid Robots — positioning Tesla at the forefront of automation and productivity, potentially the most transformative product since the iPhone.

   
   

Together, these milestones redefine Tesla’s identity. It’s no longer just an automaker — it’s an AI, robotics, and energy ecosystem that could reshape global productivity and mobility.

Why It Matters for Long-Term Shareholders

This award isn’t a bonus — it’s a performance contract. Musk’s payout only materializes if shareholders first create trillions of dollars in value. If he succeeds, Tesla could become one of the most valuable enterprises in human history — not through financial engineering, but through sustained innovation and execution.

It also preserves what Musk values most: control over the mission. If all tranches vest, his ownership could rise from roughly 12% today to 22–24%, ensuring he retains enough influence to guide Tesla’s AI and robotics technologies responsibly and in alignment with his long-term vision for humanity.

Musk has often emphasized that his motivation isn’t personal wealth — it’s mission control. He’s building technologies that could reshape civilization itself: autonomous AI, humanoid robots, neural networks. In his words:

“If someone else controlled Tesla’s AI, they could potentially misuse it. I need to have enough influence to make sure it’s aligned with humanity’s best interests.”

This compensation structure serves as his built-in safeguard — a way to remain at the helm, not to enrich himself, but to ensure the technologies he’s unleashing advance human progress rather than threaten it.

The Rowan Street View

At Rowan Street, we’ve always believed that true wealth creation happens when management and shareholders are aligned around a shared mission — with skin in the game and long-term accountability.

Elon’s new plan embodies exactly that. It’s bold. It’s audacious. And it’s capitalism at its purest form — no pay for promises, only for performance.

If it works, Tesla shareholders won’t just own a car company. They’ll own a stake in the infrastructure of the future — autonomous mobility, global energy storage, and humanoid robotics.

This is the kind of performance structure we dream of seeing across corporate America — a model of vision, discipline, and alignment that represents capitalism done right: no guarantees, no safety nets, just radical accountability tied to long-term value creation.

Best regards,

Alex and Joe

---

For more of our writings and future updates on Rowan Street’s long-term investment journey, subscribe on Substack: rowanstreet.substack.com

---

DISCLOSURES

The information contained in this letter is provided for informational purposes only, is not complete, and does not contain certain material information about our fund, including important disclosures relating to the risks, fees, expenses, liquidity restrictions and other terms of investing, and is subject to change without notice. The information contained herein does not take into account the particular investment objective or financial or other circumstances of any individual investor. An investment in our fund is suitable only for qualified investors that fully understand the risks of such an investment. An investor should review thoroughly with his or her adviser the funds definitive private placement memorandum before making an investment determination. Rowan Street is not acting as an investment adviser or otherwise making any recommendation as to an investor’s decision to invest in our funds. This document does not constitute an offer of investment advisory services by Rowan Street, nor an offering of limited partnership interests our fund; any such offering will be made solely pursuant to the fund’s private placement memorandum. An investment in our fund will be subject to a variety of risks (which are described in the fund’s definitive private placement memorandum), and there can be no assurance that the fund’s investment objective will be met or that the fund will achieve results comparable to those described in this letter, or that the fund will make any profit or will be able to avoid incurring losses. As with any investment vehicle, past performance cannot ensure any level of future results. IF applicable, fund performance information gives effect to any investments made by the fund in certain public offerings, participation in which may be restricted with respect to certain investors. As a result, performance for the specified periods with respect to any such restricted investors may differ materially from the performance of the fund. All performance information for the fund is stated net of all fees and expenses, reinvestment of interest and dividends and include allocation for incentive interest and have not been audited (except for certain year end numbers). The methodology used to determine the Top 5 holdings is the largest portfolio positions by weight. The top 5 do not reflect all fund positions. The Top 5 can and will vary at any given point and there is no guarantee the fund will meet any specific level of performance. Net returns presented are net of fund expenses and pro-forma performance fees. Rowan Street Capital does not charge fixed management fees.